Bail & Release

Bail and release articles from Daniel Brown Law, covering bail hearings, acting as a surety, detention reviews, and bail pending appeal in Ontario.

Acting as a Surety for Bail in Ontario: Duties, Risks and the 2026 Rules

Acting as a Surety for Bail in Ontario: Duties, Risks and the 2026 Rules

A surety is a person the court approves to supervise someone released on bail. The surety promises the court that the accused will attend court and obey every condition of the release order, and pledges an amount of money that can be forfeited if the accused does not. The obligation lasts until the case ends, which can take years. Since July 15, 2026, someone convicted of an indictable offence in the past ten years can be a surety only in limited circumstances. For how bail hearings work, see our Toronto bail lawyer page.

A surety is someone who agrees to take responsibility for a person accused of a crime while out on bail. Being a surety is a serious commitment. Before you accept this responsibility, here are a few things you should consider:

  • Think about getting legal advice to make sure you understand what this commitment means.
  • Do not agree to be a surety if you are not sure that you can supervise the accused person in the community.
  • If the accused person fails to obey the terms and/or conditions of the court order, you could lose the money you have pledged.
  • Your responsibility as a surety continues until the case is completely over. In some cases, this may take many months or even years.
The role
Supervise and pledgeMake sure the accused attends court and obeys every condition
Who decides
The bail courtA justice or judge approves each surety (Criminal Code s. 515(2.1))
How long
Until the case endsThrough to sentence if the accused is found guilty
If there is a breach
A forfeiture hearingA judge decides whether you pay all, part or none

What are my responsibilities as a surety?

Four stages, one promise: the accused will come to court and keep every condition.

1. Approved by the courtA justice or judge decides whether you are suitable and names you as a surety.Asks: are you suitable?
2. Sign and pledgeYou sign the release order and promise an amount. Usually no money changes hands.Asks: what is at stake?
3. Supervise to the endThe accused attends court and obeys every condition, through to sentence if there is one.Asks: can you supervise?
4. Discharged, relieved or forfeitedThe case ends, you ask to be relieved, or a breach leads to a forfeiture hearing.Asks: how does it end?
Pointillist painting of a cream front porch with two empty wooden chairs and a glowing burnt-orange lamp beside the open door

As a surety, you are making a commitment to the court. Essentially, a surety promises to make sure the accused person comes to court on time and on the right dates and promises to make sure that the accused person obeys each condition of the bail order, known in the Criminal Code since 2019 as a release order and still often called a recognizance.

Conditions of the bail may require the accused person to report to the police and obey a curfew. They may also order the accused to not possess weapons, drink alcohol and/or communicate directly or indirectly with the victim or victim's family. This means that you as the surety are also not to communicate on behalf of the accused person with the victim or the victim's family.

If you are accepted as a surety, you must sign the release order (the recognizance). It means that you agree to pay a specified amount of money if the accused person fails to obey the court order.

Conditions are not meant to be added by rote. The Supreme Court of Canada held in R v Zora, 2020 SCC 14, that every bail condition must be necessary, reasonable, the least onerous in the circumstances and sufficiently linked to a real risk, and warned that broad conditions such as “obey the rules of the house” can be problematic. A condition you cannot realistically supervise is worth raising before you sign, not after. The obligation also outlasts adjournments: the order continues to bind the accused and the sureties until the trial is over or, if the accused is found guilty, until sentence (Criminal Code ss. 523(1), 763 and 764).

Is it against the law to accept money to be a surety? Accepting a fee or being paid back in return for acting as a surety is against the law and a person found engaging in such behavior can be charged with the crime of obstructing justice. Under Criminal Code s. 139(1), it is an offence for a surety to accept or agree to accept a fee or any form of indemnity, and for anyone to indemnify a surety. It carries up to two years in prison. That is why Canada has no commercial bail bonds.

What are the qualifications of a surety?

The judge or justice of the peace will decide whether you are suitable to act as a surety. Qualifications of a surety will vary depending on the allegations or charges against the accused. The judge will look at your finances, personal character and background. You may have to give evidence in court and be cross-examined about your qualifications.

The court can name particular people as sureties (Criminal Code s. 515(2.1)). Since July 15, 2026, the Bail and Sentencing Reform Act, S.C. 2026, c. 11, has added a bar: a person convicted of an indictable offence within the ten years before the release order cannot be named unless the court is satisfied that no other suitable surety is available and that naming them is in the interests of justice. If the court does name them, it must put its reasons on the record (s. 515(2.12)). The rule applies to bail proceedings that were already under way when it came into force. A conviction for a hybrid offence counts if the Crown prosecuted it by indictment, but not if it proceeded summarily (Interpretation Act s. 34(1)). It is worth checking a proposed surety’s record early and lining up a second surety.

Your finances

You must show you have the amount you are pledging, for example with bank statements or a property deed. The pledge is only as meaningful as your ability to pay it.

Your character and background

The court looks at who you are, your relationship with the accused, and whether you have a criminal record or outstanding charges yourself.

Your ability to supervise

Where you live and work, how much time you can spend with the accused, and what you would do if a condition were broken.

Your record: the 2026 rule

A court must not name as a surety anyone convicted of an indictable offence in the ten years before the release order, unless no other suitable surety is available and it is in the interests of justice (Criminal Code s. 515(2.11)).

Our lawyers prepare every proposed surety for the questions the justice and the prosecutor are likely to ask. One wrong answer can be the difference between a release and a detention order. See how the rest of the hearing works on our bail hearings page.

Does every bail need a surety?

A surety is not the starting point. Every accused person has the right not to be denied reasonable bail without just cause (Charter s. 11(e)), and the Criminal Code sets out the forms of release as a ladder, from least to most onerous:

  1. Release with no financial obligation (Criminal Code s. 515(2)(a))
  2. The accused’s own promise to pay an amount if they breach (s. 515(2)(b))
  3. One or more sureties, with or without the accused’s promise to pay (s. 515(2)(c))
  4. A deposit of money or other security (s. 515(2)(d))
  5. A deposit, with or without sureties, for someone who lives out of the province or more than 200 km away (s. 515(2)(e))

Outside reverse-onus cases, the court cannot move up a rung unless the prosecution shows why the less onerous forms would be inadequate (s. 515(2.01)), and before requiring a surety it must be satisfied a surety is the least onerous form of release possible (s. 515(2.03)). In R v Antic, 2017 SCC 27, the Supreme Court of Canada called a surety release “one of the most onerous forms of release” and held that a surety should not be imposed unless all the less onerous forms have been considered and rejected.

The 2026 reforms changed this for reverse-onus cases. Where the accused must justify release, the ladder rule in s. 515(2.01) no longer applies (s. 515(2.04)), and the accused must clearly demonstrate that the proposed release plan addresses the risks (s. 515(6)). In those cases a well-prepared surety is often the core of the plan. The list of reverse-onus offences is on our bail hearings page.

No surety available? Ontario has Bail Verification and Supervision programs, run by community agencies such as the John Howard Society, for people who qualify for bail but lack the money or community ties to meet their conditions. The program verifies information for the court, may require the accused to report to it or to the police, helps them keep their conditions and connects them to services. Ontario’s Crown Prosecution Manual recognizes that supervision may be available through the program instead of a surety.

Do I need to pay the money pledged on the bail right away?

Pointillist painting of a cream piggy bank on a sunny windowsill beside a pot of herbs and one burnt-orange coin

In most cases, a person signing bail need only promise to pay the money they are pledging at a future date if the accused fails to comply with the bail order. However, in some cases, in addition to the surety's pledge to pay a specified amount of money, the accused will be required to deposit a sum of money to the court. That is now rare: the court must favour a promise to pay over a deposit where the accused or the surety has reasonably recoverable assets (Criminal Code s. 515(2.02)), and in R v Antic the Supreme Court held that cash bail should be relied on only in exceptional circumstances, in an amount within the readily available means of the accused and the sureties. A pledge has the same pull as cash: either way, the money is lost if the accused breaches.

Where there has been a deposit of cash by the accused person, or by the surety on behalf of the accused and the case is over, that money is returned to the accused person and not to the surety. Care should be exercised to ensure that the surety who posts a cash bail has a clear agreement with the accused person to return the cash deposit.

A pledge and a cash deposit compared (Criminal Code s. 515(2))
Question Pledge (promise to pay) Cash deposit
What it is A promise to pay a set amount if the accused breaks the order. Money or other security handed to the court at the start.
When money moves Only if a judge orders forfeiture after a default. Before the accused is released.
What the law prefers Favoured whenever the accused or surety has reasonably recoverable assets (s. 515(2.02)). Only in exceptional circumstances, never more than the accused and sureties can raise (Antic).
After a breach A judge decides whether to forfeit all, part or none; the surety becomes a judgment debtor for any amount ordered (s. 771). The deposit is sent to the court clerk and can be forfeited (ss. 770(4), 771(4)).
When the case ends The pledge simply ends. Nothing is paid. Returned once the case is over and the bail terms have been followed.

How do I end my obligations as a surety?

Pointillist painting of a white garden gate standing open onto a sunny path, a burnt-orange ribbon on the gatepost

You may decide that you are no longer willing or able to supervise the accused person. In this case you have two options:

  1. Bring the accused to court yourself

    You may bring the accused to the court personally and ask that you be relieved of your responsibilities. During the court’s sittings and before trial, a surety can discharge the obligation by giving the accused into the custody of the court (Criminal Code s. 767).

  2. Or apply in writing

    You may come to the court and apply in writing to the court to be relieved of your duties. The court will then issue an order for the arrest of the accused person: a written order for committal that is given to you, and that lets you or any police officer arrest the accused and take them to jail (s. 766(1)–(2)).

  3. The court may substitute a new surety

    Instead of sending the accused to jail, the court can substitute another suitable person as surety. Once the new surety signs, the original surety is discharged (s. 767.1).

  4. Your obligations end

    Once the accused is in custody and the committal is endorsed on the release order, the order is cancelled and the sureties are discharged (s. 766(3)–(4)). The accused is then brought back before a justice for a new bail hearing (s. 769).

Your safety comes first. If you believe the accused person is a threat to your safety, you should not attempt to bring the accused person back to court yourself. Once a court order is made, the police can arrest the accused, and your obligations will be over once the accused is in custody and the committal is endorsed.

If the problem is a condition rather than the surety, the release can often be varied instead, with the Crown’s consent or on a review. See our bail lawyer page for bail reviews and variations.

What happens if the accused person fails to obey his bail conditions?

If the accused person fails to appear in court or breaks any other term of the bail order, the accused person may be charged with another criminal offence: failing to attend court or failing to comply with a release order, each punishable by up to two years in prison (Criminal Code s. 145(2), (5)). If the court finds a breach, it can cancel the release, and the accused must then clearly demonstrate a plan that addresses the risks (s. 524(4)). See failing to comply with bail conditions for how those charges are defended.

If the person breaches the court order or fails to appear for his/her court date, the Crown may ask the court to make you pay the money you committed as a surety. This does not depend on the accused being convicted of a new charge. A hearing will be scheduled. You and the accused person will be given at least 10 days notice of the date and place of the hearing.

The hearing is called estreatment. It will give you an opportunity to explain why you should not lose your money. After hearing from you and the prosecutor, the judge may order that you pay all, part, or none of your money pledged on the bail.

Further legal action may be taken against you to collect the amount owing.

How a forfeiture (estreatment) hearing works

  1. The default is recorded

    A court that knows of the breach endorses a certificate on the release order setting out the default, the reason for it if known, and the names of the accused and the sureties (Criminal Code s. 770).

  2. A forfeiture hearing is set

    On the Crown’s or the clerk’s request, a judge fixes a hearing. Each surety must be sent notice at least 10 days before it, requiring them to show cause why the amount should not be forfeited (s. 771(1)).

  3. The judge decides how much

    After hearing from the surety and the prosecutor, the judge has a discretion to forfeit all, part or none of the amount (s. 771(2)).

  4. The Crown collects

    A surety ordered to pay becomes a judgment debtor of the Crown. The order can be enforced like a civil judgment, and a deposit is simply transferred (s. 771(3)–(4)). If it still cannot be collected, a judge can hold a further hearing and, in the end, even order the surety imprisoned (s. 773).

Daniel Brown is a criminal lawyer with extensive experience assisting people who have unsuccessfully acted as sureties and now risk the possibility of losing the money pledged on the bail. If you are facing the possibility of losing your bail money, contact Daniel Brown Law immediately to arrange a consultation. Alternatively, you can follow this link for more information on bail hearings in Toronto.

Why Choose Daniel Brown Law?

Daniel Brown Law is a leading Canadian criminal defence firm. Bail hearings, and the sureties who make them work, are daily work for our lawyers.

A nationally recognized defence firm

Ranked among Canada’s top criminal law boutiques by Canadian Lawyer, listed for criminal defence by The Globe and Mail and Best Law Firms, and voted Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services by Toronto Star readers.

Sureties ready for every question

We meet proposed sureties before the hearing, go through the questions the Crown and the court are likely to ask, and build the supervision plan around what they can realistically do.

A plan built for the 2026 rules

We check each surety against the new ten-year record bar and, in reverse-onus cases, build a release plan that clearly addresses the risks.

Help when a pledge is at risk

We act for sureties at forfeiture hearings, where the judge decides whether they pay all, part or none of what they pledged.

Recognized by the profession and the public

Daniel Brown Law is ranked among Canada’s top criminal law boutiques by Canadian Lawyer, listed by The Globe and Mail and Best Law Firms for criminal defence, and voted Best Legal Services by Toronto Star readers. Five of its lawyers are recognized by Best Lawyers in Canada for criminal defence.

The Globe and Mail Best Law Firms 2026, Criminal Law

Best Law Firms: Criminal Law

The Globe and Mail, 2026

Canadian Lawyer Top Criminal Law Boutique 2026-27

Top Criminal Law Boutique

Canadian Lawyer, 2026–27

Best Law Firms Canada, Criminal Defence Tier 1, 2026

Criminal Defence, Tier 1

Best Law Firms Canada, 2026

Best Lawyers in Canada 2027, Daniel Brown Law

Best Lawyers in Canada

Criminal Defence, 2027

Toronto Star Readers' Choice winner seal

Toronto Star Readers’ Choice

Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services, repeat winner

Chambers Canada 2027, Ranked in Canada, Daniel Brown Law

Crime, Nationwide

Chambers Canada, 2027

The firm and its lawyers have been repeatedly recognized for excellence in criminal defence:

Acting as a Surety — Frequently Asked Questions

Short answers to the questions sureties ask most often.

Becoming a surety

What is a surety for bail?

A surety is someone who agrees to take responsibility for a person accused of a crime while out on bail. The surety supervises the accused, makes sure they attend court and obey their conditions, and pledges an amount of money that can be forfeited if they do not.

Who can be a surety?

Anyone the court finds suitable. The judge or justice looks at the surety’s finances, character, background and ability to supervise, and the surety may have to testify and be cross-examined. Since July 15, 2026, a person convicted of an indictable offence in the previous ten years can be named only if no other suitable surety is available and it is in the interests of justice (Criminal Code s. 515(2.11)).

Is a surety always required for bail?

No. Outside reverse-onus cases, a surety may be required only where no less onerous form of release would do (s. 515(2.01), (2.03); R v Antic, 2017 SCC 27). In reverse-onus cases the 2026 reforms switched that ladder rule off, and a surety is often the heart of the release plan.

What if nobody can act as a surety?

An accused person who qualifies for bail but has no surety may be supervised by Ontario’s Bail Verification and Supervision Program, which verifies information for the court and supervises people in the community.

Does the accused have to live with the surety?

Not always. A court can make living with the surety a condition where it is needed to address a real risk, and it often is. Like every bail condition, it must be necessary, reasonable and the least onerous that will do (R v Zora, 2020 SCC 14).

Your obligations and risks

Is it against the law to accept money to be a surety?

Yes. Accepting a fee or being paid back in return for acting as a surety is against the law and a person found engaging in such behavior can be charged with the crime of obstructing justice (Criminal Code s. 139(1)), which carries up to two years in prison.

How long does a surety’s responsibility last?

Your responsibility as a surety continues until the case is completely over: until the trial ends or, if the accused is found guilty, until sentence. In some cases, this may take many months or even years.

Can a surety be charged or go to jail?

A surety is not charged with the accused’s breach, but can lose the money pledged. A surety who takes a fee or indemnity can be charged with obstructing justice. And if a forfeiture judgment cannot be collected, a judge can, after a further hearing, order the surety imprisoned (s. 773).

Do I need to pay the money pledged on the bail right away?

Usually not. In most cases, a person signing bail need only promise to pay the money they are pledging at a future date if the accused fails to comply with the bail order. A cash deposit is ordered only in exceptional circumstances.

Do I get my money back?

A pledge is never paid unless a judge orders forfeiture, so there is nothing to get back. A cash deposit is returned once the case is over and the bail terms have been followed, but it goes back to the accused, not to the surety who posted it, so agree in writing that the accused will repay the surety.

Getting out, and forfeiture

How do I end my obligations as a surety?

Bring the accused to court and ask to be relieved, or apply in writing for an order for the accused’s committal (Criminal Code ss. 766–767). The court may instead substitute a new surety (s. 767.1). If you believe the accused is a threat to your safety, do not try to bring them to court yourself.

What happens if the accused person fails to obey his bail conditions?

The accused may be charged with another criminal offence, and the Crown may apply to forfeit the surety’s pledge, whether or not the accused is convicted of a new charge.

What is a bail estreatment hearing?

The hearing on the Crown’s application to forfeit a surety’s pledge. You receive at least 10 days’ notice, can explain why you should not lose your money, and the judge may order you to pay all, part or none of it (s. 771).

Asked to be a surety, or facing forfeiture? Talk to Daniel Brown Law

Whether you are preparing to testify at a bail hearing or trying to keep the money you pledged, talk to us before the court date. To arrange a consultation with Daniel Brown Law, contact our team or call our office at (416) 297-7200.

Phone: (416) 297-7200
Office: Daniel Brown Law, 400–103 Church St., Toronto, ON M5C 2G3

Bail Pending Appeal in Ontario

Bail Pending Appeal in Ontario

Bail pending appeal is release from custody while your appeal against a conviction or a sentence waits to be heard. In Ontario a single judge of the Court of Appeal decides it, once a notice of appeal has been filed, and the burden is on the person asking to be released: they must establish that the appeal is not frivolous, that they will surrender back into custody, and that their detention is not necessary in the public interest.

One of the most important beginning steps in a criminal appeal, where the client has been given a jail sentence, is to seek bail pending appeal. This page explains the bail process for criminal appeals in Toronto and across Ontario. Please follow the links for further information about the criminal appeal process or appeals initiated by the Crown attorney.

The appeal process is lengthy. Without bail pending appeal a person can serve most or all of a sentence before the appeal is ever argued, which is why the application is normally brought within days of sentencing rather than months. Anyone who needs help with an appeal-related issue should immediately consult a criminal appeal lawyer for advice.

Daniel Brown Law brings and answers bail pending appeal applications at the Court of Appeal for Ontario, at the Superior Court of Justice on summary conviction appeals, and at the Supreme Court of Canada.

Who decides
A single appeal judgeA panel can review the decision under s. 680
What you must show
Three thingsNot frivolous, will surrender, detention not necessary in the public interest
Notice to the Crown
3 clear daysCourt of Appeal Criminal Appeal Rules, r. 22(4)
Who carries the burden
You doThe presumption of innocence no longer applies

What do you have to prove to get bail pending appeal?

The Criminal Code sets out one test for a conviction appeal and a different, harder one for an appeal against sentence alone. Both start from the same place: the judge may order release only if the appellant establishes each part.

1. Is the appeal frivolous?You must show the appeal, or the application for leave to appeal, is not frivolous. It is a very low bar, and an appeal with no foundation at all fails here and goes no further.s. 679(3)(a)
2. Will you come back?You must show you will surrender yourself into custody in accordance with the terms of the release order. Any history of failing to appear for court, and anything that reads as a flight risk, is weighed here.s. 679(3)(b)
3. Is your detention necessary in the public interest?The criterion that is actually fought about. It has two halves: public safety, and public confidence in the administration of justice.s. 679(3)(c)

Section 679(3) of the Criminal Code, as applied in R v Oland, 2017 SCC 17. If you are appealing your sentence only, section 679(4) applies instead: leave to appeal the sentence has to be granted first, and you must show the appeal has sufficient merit that it would cause unnecessary hardship if you were held in custody. The surrender and public interest criteria are the same.

Key considerations

The burden is entirely on you

The burden is entirely on the applicant seeking bail. He or she no longer benefits from the presumption of innocence. A conviction has been entered, and the Criminal Code allows release only where the appellant establishes every part of the test.

A notice of appeal comes first

Before an appeal bail can be sought, a notice of appeal must be filed with the court. The notice of appeal sets out the basic reasons for appeal and is required to commence the appeal process. In Ontario a convicted person files it within 30 days after the day the sentence is imposed.

The grounds of appeal do a great deal of the work

The Court places significant emphasis on being able to establish that there is an arguable ground of appeal; i.e. that there is some chance that the appeal will be successful. It is very important that any bail application fully set out the proposed grounds of appeal. Where the Crown raises public confidence, the judge looks past the bare “not frivolous” threshold at whether the grounds clearly surpass it.

Surrender is a term of every order

Every bail pending appeal has a term that the client must surrender to the jail from where he or she was released. The Criminal Code requires a surrender condition in every release order pending appeal, and the order fixes a surrender date, normally shortly before the appeal is argued. That date can be extended on application, but failing to surrender is deemed to be an abandonment of the appeal.

Release is not the only thing that can be paused

Pending an appeal the Court of Appeal, or a judge of it, can also suspend a fine, an order of forfeiture, a restitution order, a victim surcharge, a probation order or a conditional sentence order where that is in the interests of justice, and a judge can stay a driving prohibition. See the criminal appeal process.

What does “the public interest” actually mean?

This is the criterion most appeal bail hearings turn on. The Supreme Court of Canada settled how it works in R v Oland: it has two components, and the second is a balance between two things the public cares about at the same time.

Mosaic tile artwork of a level two-pan balance scale, one pan picked out in burnt orange

Public safety

Asks: would releasing you put anyone at risk?

The first component. It essentially tracks the familiar question at a bail hearing before trial: is there a substantial likelihood that you would commit an offence or interfere with the administration of justice if you were released? Where there is no appreciable risk, this part is answered quickly, but residual concerns that fall short of justifying detention on their own still count in the balance below.

Enforceability

Asks: should the judgment be obeyed right now?

Society expects a court's judgment to be enforced when it is made. The seriousness of the crime drives this side of the balance — its gravity, the circumstances in which it was committed, and the length of imprisonment you are facing. Lingering flight or safety concerns strengthen it; the absence of them weakens it.

Reviewability

Asks: is the appeal worth waiting for?

Our justice system is not infallible, and a person who challenges the legality of a conviction should not have to serve all or most of the sentence only to learn on appeal that the conviction was unlawful. The strength of the grounds of appeal is central here. The judge looks at whether the grounds are legally plausible and founded in the record, not at whether they would virtually guarantee a new trial or an acquittal — demanding that much is an error of law.

The reasonable member of the public

Asks: whose confidence is being measured?

Public confidence is measured through the eyes of a person who is thoughtful, dispassionate, informed of the circumstances of the case and respectful of society's fundamental values. It is not uninformed public opinion, and it is not the reaction to a headline.

R v Oland, 2017 SCC 17, following R v Farinacci (1993), 86 C.C.C. (3d) 32 (Ont. C.A.). Also relevant to this factor is the issue of enforceability of court orders versus the right of the accused to review the correctness of the decision at trial. There is no formula: the balance is qualitative and contextual. A serious offence and a long sentence raise the enforceability interest — but where all or a significant part of that sentence would be served before the appeal could be decided, bail becomes more important, not less, if the right of review is to mean anything. A good surety plan can offset public interest concerns.

Which court decides whether you are released?

The route depends on how you were tried and what you are appealing. The test changes with it.

Your appeal Who decides release What you must establish
Conviction appeal, indictableCourt of Appeal for Ontario A single judge of the Court of Appeal, once the notice of appeal or the leave application is filed The appeal is not frivolous; you will surrender; your detention is not necessary in the public interest s. 679(3)
Sentence appeal onlyCourt of Appeal for Ontario A single judge — but the motion for leave to appeal sentence is heard and decided first The appeal has sufficient merit that detention would cause unnecessary hardship; you will surrender; your detention is not necessary in the public interest s. 679(4)
Summary conviction appealSuperior Court of Justice The summary conviction appeal court hearing the appeal You remain in custody unless that court makes a release order, which must include a surrender condition s. 816
Appeal or leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of CanadaNotice filed and served first A single judge of the Court of Appeal The same three-part test as a conviction appeal, including in summary conviction matters s. 679(1)(c), (3), (8)
After a new trial is orderedThe conviction has been set aside A judge of the Court of Appeal, exercising a bail court’s powers Ordinary bail rules apply, as though you were charged with the offence for the first time s. 679(7.1)

A further appeal from the summary conviction appeal court to the Court of Appeal needs leave and must raise a question of law alone; on that appeal sections 673 to 689 apply, so release under section 679 is available there too. A reference directed by the Minister of Justice is treated like a conviction appeal. Where a driving prohibition is under appeal, a judge of the court appealed to can stay it on conditions.

How does a bail pending appeal application work?

It often takes a couple of weeks on average, sometimes longer, to prepare materials good enough to maximise the chances of release. The clock that matters is the one that starts at sentencing.

Mosaic tile artwork of an hourglass with burnt-orange sand running through it
  1. Retain appeal counsel, ideally before you are sentenced

    Given the time required to properly assemble appeal bail materials, it is often suggested to retain an appeal lawyer in advance of the sentencing hearing to commence work on the bail application where the imposition of a jail sentence is likely. In that case the application can often be filed with the Court in advance of the sentencing hearing so that the bail hearing can be argued the day following sentencing. Done properly, it is not uncommon to spend less than a single day in jail before being released on bail pending appeal.

  2. File the notice of appeal

    Nothing can be sought until the appeal exists. The notice sets out the basic grounds, and in Ontario a convicted person files it within 30 days after the day the sentence is imposed. A judge can extend that time, but an extension is never guaranteed. On a sentence-only appeal the motion for leave to appeal is brought at the same time and decided first.

  3. Build the application record

    The record contains the notice of application, the notice of appeal, the information or indictment, any release orders made earlier in the case, the supporting affidavits and a draft release order for the judge to sign.

  4. Prepare the affidavits and the release plan

    The affidavits set out the particulars of the conviction and sentence, your bail history, your date of birth, where you have lived for the past three years and where you would live if released, your employment, your criminal record, the proposed sureties and the amounts they would be liable for, and your agreements to surrender, to comply with every condition and to pursue the appeal diligently. On a sentence appeal they must also explain the unnecessary hardship that detention would cause.

  5. Serve the Crown three clear days before the hearing

    The Crown states its position by noon the day before. A judge can abridge that notice period where the Crown consents. Both sides attend the argument, and either may cross-examine on the other’s affidavits if a judge directs it.

  6. The hearing, and the order

    If the judge does not refuse the application, the judge must make a release order, with a surrender condition and the standard appeal conditions: notify the court and the Crown of any change of address or any new charge within 24 hours, comply with every condition, and pursue the appeal with due diligence. Once you comply with the order, the institution holding you must release you immediately.

What happens if a judge refuses bail pending appeal?

A refusal by a single judge is not always the end of it. There are two routes, and they do different things.

Court sketch of robed defence counsel before a panel of judges in a historic courtroom

A review by a panel

Asks: did the single judge go wrong?

The Chief Justice or Acting Chief Justice of the Court of Appeal can direct that the decision be reviewed by the court, which in practice means a panel of three judges. The panel defers to the judge's findings of fact unless there is a palpable and overriding error, but it can substitute its own decision where the judge made an error of law or principle that was material to the outcome, or where the decision was clearly unwarranted. The Chief Justice directs a review where either of those is arguable. On consent of the parties a single judge of the court can conduct it.

An expedited appeal

Asks: how soon can the appeal itself be heard?

Where release is refused, or a release order is cancelled, a judge may give whatever directions are necessary to expedite the hearing of the appeal. Where much of the sentence would otherwise be served before the appeal could be decided, that is an imperfect but real way of keeping the right of review meaningful.

Sections 680 and 679(10) of the Criminal Code; R v Oland, 2017 SCC 17, at paragraphs 61 and 64. An application for a section 680 direction starts with a notice of application and a case management conference with the Chief Justice. Section 680 was last touched by the Bail and Sentencing Reform Act (2026, c. 11), which only updated its cross-references; the test for release under section 679 was not changed by that Act or by the 2026 reforms that followed it.

Why choose Daniel Brown Law for a bail pending appeal?

Appeal bail is a specialised hearing in a court with its own rules, its own record and its own judges.

A nationally recognized defence firm

What it means for you

Daniel Brown Law is a leading Canadian criminal defence firm, recognized for criminal defence and appellate practice by Canadian Lawyer, The Globe and Mail, Best Law Firms and Toronto Star readers. You are retaining a firm with that record behind it rather than a single lawyer, and the appeal is staffed by whoever on our team is best placed to argue it.

An appellate practice, not an afterthought

What it means for you

Our lawyers argue conviction and sentence appeals at the Court of Appeal for Ontario and at the Supreme Court of Canada. The merits of an appeal have to be articulated properly at the bail stage, and the lawyer who will argue the appeal is usually the one best placed to do it.

We can start before the sentence lands

What it means for you

Where a jail sentence is a realistic outcome, we prepare the bail record while the sentencing is still ahead of us, so the application can be argued the day after. That is the difference between a night in custody and several months of it.

Release plans built to answer the real objection

What it means for you

A good surety plan can make the difference between being released and being detained. We build the plan around whatever the Crown is going to say — the seriousness of the offence, a flight concern, a record — and put it in front of the judge in a form the court can approve on the day.

Recognized by the profession and the public

Daniel Brown Law is ranked among Canada's top criminal law boutiques by Canadian Lawyer, listed by The Globe and Mail and Best Law Firms for criminal defence, and voted Best Legal Services by Toronto Star readers. Five of its lawyers are recognized by Best Lawyers in Canada for criminal defence.

The Globe and Mail Best Law Firms 2026, Criminal Law

Best Law Firms: Criminal Law

The Globe and Mail, 2026

Canadian Lawyer Top Criminal Law Boutique 2026-27

Top Criminal Law Boutique

Canadian Lawyer, 2026–27

Best Law Firms Canada, Criminal Defence Tier 1, 2026

Criminal Defence, Tier 1

Best Law Firms Canada, 2026

Best Lawyers in Canada 2027, Daniel Brown Law

Best Lawyers in Canada

Criminal Defence, 2027

Toronto Star Readers' Choice winner seal

Toronto Star Readers’ Choice

Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services, repeat winner

Chambers Canada 2027, Ranked in Canada, Daniel Brown Law

Crime, Nationwide

Chambers Canada, 2027

The firm and its lawyers have been repeatedly recognized for excellence in criminal defence:

Frequently asked questions about bail pending appeal in criminal cases

The answers from our original article, corrected to the current law and grouped by topic.

The basics

What is bail pending appeal?

Obtaining bail pending appeal secures the client's release from custody while his or her appeal is litigated before the Appeal Court. The appeal process is lengthy, so failure to obtain bail pending appeal can mean waiting months or even years in jail prior to the appeal being heard.

Can you get bail after you have already been convicted and sentenced?

Yes. Bail pending appeal exists precisely for that situation. It is a different thing from bail before trial: the conviction stands unless and until the appeal succeeds, the presumption of innocence no longer applies, and the burden of justifying release is on you rather than on the Crown. What you have to show is set out in section 679 of the Criminal Code.

What must be done before an appeal bail is sought?

Before an appeal bail can be sought, a notice of appeal must be filed with the court. The notice of appeal sets out the basic reasons for appeal and is required to commence the appeal process. In Ontario a convicted person files it within 30 days after the day the sentence is imposed. If you are appealing your sentence only, you also need leave to appeal that sentence, and the motion for leave is heard and decided before the release application.

Does bail pending appeal apply to summary conviction appeals?

The mechanism is different. A summary conviction appeal goes to the Superior Court of Justice, and the Criminal Code says that an appellant who is in custody stays in custody unless that court makes a release order, which must include a condition that the person surrender back into custody. Once the order is made and complied with, the institution has to release the person immediately. If the case goes further — to the Court of Appeal with leave on a question of law alone, or to the Supreme Court of Canada — section 679 applies again.

How the hearing works

How quickly can an appeal bail be heard by the judge?

Once the notice of appeal is filed, a bail application can be brought before the appeal court on providing three clear days notice to the Crown Attorney, unless the Crown consents to a shorter period and a judge permits it. That said, it often takes a couple of weeks on average, sometimes longer, to prepare proper materials to maximize the chances of obtaining bail.

Given the time required to properly assemble appeal bail materials, it is often suggested to retain an appeal lawyer in advance of the sentencing hearing to commence work on the bail application where the imposition of a jail sentence is likely. In this case, a bail pending appeal application can often be filed with the Court in advance of the sentencing hearing so that the bail hearing can be argued the day following sentencing. Done properly, it is not uncommon to spend less than a single day in jail before being released on bail pending appeal.

What is the difference between an appeal bail hearing and a bail hearing before trial?

Unlike bail at trial, the sureties on bail pending appeal rarely testify in court. The surety information, including the plan of release and proposed bond, is set out in a sworn affidavit. It is very important that the surety affidavits are well prepared and set out both the plan of release and the client's track record on previous release orders, including bail while at trial. A good surety plan can make the difference between being released and being detained.

Either side can still ask to cross-examine on the affidavits, in the manner a judge directs, and both sides attend the argument of the application.

Who decides whether to release a person on bail pending appeal?

The decision to release a person on an appeal bail is made by a single judge from the Appeal Court. This judge may or may not continue as the judge on the actual appeal hearing after the bail hearing stage is completed. If the application is refused, the Chief Justice can direct that the decision be reviewed by the court, normally a panel of three judges.

Can a surety with a criminal record still be approved?

It became harder in 2026. Under changes made by the Bail and Sentencing Reform Act, a court must not name a person as a surety if that person was convicted of an indictable offence within the previous ten years, unless the court is satisfied that no other suitable surety is available and that naming them is in the interests of justice — and if it does, it has to put its reasons on the record. A release order pending appeal is a release order under section 515, so this rule applies to appeal bail as well. It is worth identifying a second surety early.

The test

What factors will a judge consider at an appeal bail hearing?

The key to obtaining bail on appeal is well prepared bail application materials. The burden is entirely on the applicant seeking bail. He or she no longer benefits from the presumption of innocence. The applicant must meet a three-part test: (a) the appeal is not frivolous; (b) he will surrender himself into custody in accordance with the terms of the release order; and, (c) his detention is not necessary in the public interest.

The Court places significant emphasis on being able to establish that there is an arguable ground of appeal; i.e. that there is some chance that the appeal will be successful. It is very important that any bail application fully set out the proposed grounds of appeal. The “not frivolous” standard itself is a very low bar; where the Crown puts public confidence in issue, the judge takes a closer look at whether the grounds clearly surpass it.

Every bail pending appeal has a term that the client must surrender to the jail from where he or she was released on the day before the appeal hearing. The Court must be satisfied that the accused will surrender as required. The Court will generally consider any prior charges of failure to appear for court or whether the person is generally a flight risk.

Finally, the Court will consider the public interest. This factor considers such issues as the seriousness of the offence and the person's level of risk to commit further offences. Also relevant to this factor is the issue of enforceability of court orders versus the right of the accused to review the correctness of the decision at trial. If a long sentence is imposed, the Court may consider it not to be in the public interest to grant bail. A good surety plan can offset public interest concerns.

The Supreme Court of Canada added an important qualification in R v Oland: where all or a significant part of the sentence would be served before the appeal could be heard, bail takes on greater significance rather than less, because otherwise the right to have the conviction reviewed becomes meaningless. And the balance is not resolved by a formula — it is qualitative and contextual, measured through the eyes of a reasonable member of the public who is thoughtful, dispassionate and informed of the circumstances of the case.

Is the test different if I am only appealing my sentence?

Yes. Section 679(4) of the Criminal Code applies instead of section 679(3), and it has an extra requirement at the front: leave to appeal the sentence must already have been granted. You then have to establish that the appeal has sufficient merit that, in the circumstances, it would cause unnecessary hardship if you were detained in custody, that you will surrender into custody as required, and that your detention is not necessary in the public interest. The supporting affidavit has to spell out what that unnecessary hardship would be.

If things go wrong

Can you appeal a decision refusing bail pending appeal?

Not by way of a fresh appeal, but the Criminal Code provides a review. On the direction of the Chief Justice or Acting Chief Justice of the Court of Appeal, the decision can be reviewed by the court, which can vary it or substitute the decision that should have been made. The review panel defers to the judge's findings of fact unless there is a palpable and overriding error; it can intervene where the judge made a material error of law or principle, or where the decision was clearly unwarranted. If release is refused, a judge can also give directions to expedite the hearing of the appeal itself.

What happens if you do not surrender on time?

Every release order pending appeal requires you to surrender into custody in accordance with its terms, and the standard Court of Appeal order records your acknowledgment that failing to do so is deemed to be an abandonment of the appeal. The order can be varied to extend the surrender date, but the court will want evidence that you have been complying with your conditions, that your sureties are willing to continue, and that the appeal is being moved along. Breaching any other condition can lead to the order being revoked and to a return to custody.

Should my trial lawyer conduct the bail pending appeal hearing?

It is very important to properly articulate the merits of the appeal at the bail hearing stage. An experienced appeal lawyer is often in the best position to assist the Court in understanding the arguments that may lead to a conviction being overturned. Failure to convince the Court of the merits of the appeal can result in the bail being denied. It also helps to have a lawyer familiar with the procedures and judges at the appeal court to best present the client's case for bail pending appeal. Therefore, retaining a trial lawyer to address an appeal bail may negatively impact the client's chances of success on that hearing.

Mosaic tile artwork of an open doorway with light spilling across the floor, the door in burnt orange

Facing a jail sentence, or already in custody?

A client who is granted bail pending appeal is in a much better position to assist his or her lawyer in presenting the case to the court. Hiring an experienced appeal lawyer is essential to ensure the best outcome at this critical stage of the appeal proceeding. To discuss a criminal appeal issue contact Daniel Brown Law at 416-297-7200 for a confidential consultation. We appear at the Court of Appeal for Ontario, at the Superior Court of Justice and in courthouses across the province.

Peace Bonds in Ontario Criminal Cases

Peace Bonds in Ontario Criminal Cases

A peace bond is a court order requiring you to keep the peace and be of good behaviour, normally for 12 months. It is not a conviction, it is not an admission of guilt, and it does not give you a criminal record. That is why agreeing to enter into one is one of the most common ways a criminal charge in Ontario is resolved without a trial and without a record.

A peace bond is a court order imposed by a judge in a criminal proceeding. Agreeing to a peace bond or having one imposed on you can have significant legal consequences. This page explains the law surrounding peace bonds in Canadian criminal cases: what a peace bond is, the different kinds, what conditions come with one, what a breach costs you, and how a peace bond is used to bring a criminal charge to an end.

Daniel Brown Law negotiates and contests peace bonds in courthouses across Ontario, in domestic assault, criminal harassment, uttering threats, assault and mischief cases among others.

The order
Criminal Code s. 810A recognizance to keep the peace and be of good behaviour
How long
Up to 12 monthsUp to two years, or five for terrorism, under the specialised sections
Criminal record
NoneNo conviction, no finding of guilt, no admission of wrongdoing
If you breach it
Up to 4 yearsBreach of recognizance is a separate offence, s. 811

How does a peace bond work?

A peace bond is preventive, not punitive. The court is not asked whether you did something; it is asked whether someone has reasonable grounds to fear that you will.

1. Someone swears an informationA person who fears on reasonable grounds that you will cause personal injury to them, to their intimate partner or to their child, or will damage their property, lays an information before a justice. No charge has to have been laid against you.s. 810(1)
2. The court decides whether the fear is reasonableThe justice or summary conviction court must be satisfied, by the evidence adduced, that the person has reasonable grounds for the fear. Nothing has to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt and you are not found guilty of anything.s. 810(3)
3. You enter into the recognizanceIf it is satisfied, the court may order you to enter into a recognizance, with or without sureties, to keep the peace and be of good behaviour for not more than 12 months, on whatever reasonable conditions it considers desirable.Refuse, and the court may jail you for up to 12 months — s. 810(3.01)

Section 810 also reaches a fear that the person will commit an offence under section 162.1 — distributing an intimate image without consent. Because the court makes no finding of guilt, a peace bond can be entered into even where the evidence would not support a conviction, and that is precisely why it is useful to both sides.

Key considerations

It is not a finding of guilt

A person who signs a peace bond is not required to acknowledge any criminal wrongdoing before signing the bond. It is not an admission of guilt nor will it result in a criminal record. By signing the bond, you are agreeing only that in the circumstances of the case the person who laid the information had reasonable grounds to fear for their own safety, or the safety of their intimate partner or child, or to fear damage to their property.

It is a court order all the same

A peace bond is a court order, and it is a criminal offence to intentionally violate any of the terms contained in the order. The conditions bind you for their full length whether or not the person who asked for the bond later changes their mind about wanting it.

You can refuse — at a price

Nobody can be forced to enter into a recognizance. But if the court is satisfied that the fear is reasonable and you fail or refuse to enter into the bond, it may commit you to prison for up to 12 months. Refusing is a decision to make with a lawyer, not at the counter.

It can be varied while it runs

Either the person who laid the information or the person bound by the bond can apply to the court to vary the conditions fixed in the recognizance. A condition that has stopped making sense — a no-contact term where the parties have reconciled, a no-go order over a workplace — can be revisited rather than endured.

What conditions can a peace bond impose?

Every peace bond carries the same core promise. What is negotiated — and what people actually live with for a year — are the conditions the court adds around it.

Torn-paper neighbourhood map with a burnt-orange ring drawn around one house, the other houses outside it

Keep the peace and be of good behaviour

In every peace bond

A peace bond is an official promise made by someone to the Court to abide by certain rules. Usually those rules require a person to “keep the peace and be of good behaviour”, and may also require them to refrain from contacting an individual, attending a particular location or possessing a weapon for a specified period of time.

No contact, and nowhere near

The court must consider it

Before making the order the court has to consider whether the safety of the person who asked for the bond, or of their intimate partner or child, calls for a condition that you not communicate with them, directly or indirectly, and that you stay away from places where they are regularly found. In practice these are the conditions most peace bonds turn on.

No weapons

Considered in every case, with reasons

The court must consider whether it is desirable, for anyone’s safety, to prohibit you from possessing firearms, a cross-bow, prohibited or restricted weapons, firearm parts, ammunition or explosives. If it adds the condition it must say how your weapons, licences and registration certificates are to be surrendered; if it does not add one, it has to put its reasons on the record.

Drugs, alcohol and testing

Where the risk calls for it

The court may add any reasonable condition it considers desirable to secure your good conduct, including abstaining from alcohol or from drugs other than on a prescription, and providing samples of a bodily substance for analysis, either on demand where an officer has reasonable grounds to believe you have breached an abstain condition, or at regular intervals set out in a notice.

Money on the bond

With or without sureties

The recognizance sets an amount you are on the hook for, with or without sureties. Typically the monetary amount attached to the bond ranges from 500 to 2,000 dollars. You do not pay it to enter into the bond: it becomes payable only if the court orders it forfeited after a breach.

A length, and an end date

Twelve months in the ordinary case

A peace bond under s. 810 of the Criminal Code can last up to 12 months. The specialised peace bonds can run to two years — or five, for terrorism — where the person has a relevant prior conviction. When the term ends the bond simply expires. Nothing is renewed and nothing further is required of you.

What are the different kinds of peace bond?

Most peace bonds in a criminal case are ordinary section 810 bonds. The Criminal Code adds six specialised ones for particular fears, and the courts keep a common law power alongside all of them.

The peace bond What the applicant must fear Maximum length
The ordinary peace bonds. 810 Personal injury to them, their intimate partner or their child, or damage to their property — or that you will distribute an intimate image (s. 162.1) 12 months
Criminal organization and intimidations. 810.01 A criminal organization offence, or intimidation of a justice system participant or a journalist under s. 423.1. The Attorney General must consent 12 monthsTwo years with a prior conviction of such an offence
Terrorisms. 810.011 A terrorism offence. The Attorney General must consent 12 monthsFive years with a prior terrorism conviction
Forced or under-age marriages. 810.02 A forced marriage, or a marriage of a person under 16 12 monthsTwo years with a prior conviction
Intimate partner violences. 810.03 An offence causing personal injury to your intimate partner or child, or to your intimate partner’s child 12 monthsTwo years with a prior conviction for violence against an intimate partner or a child
Sexual offence against a childs. 810.1 One of the sexual offences listed in s. 810.1(1), in respect of a person under 18 12 monthsTwo years with a prior conviction for a sexual offence against a person under 18
Serious personal injury offences. 810.2 A serious personal injury offence as defined in s. 752. The Attorney General must consent 12 monthsTwo years with a prior conviction
The common law peace bondNot in the Criminal Code A breach of the peace. It rests on the court’s long-standing power to bind a person over to keep the peace Not fixed by statute

In every one of the statutory cases, failing or refusing to enter into the recognizance once the court is satisfied can mean up to 12 months in prison. The specialised bonds allow a wider set of conditions than section 810 — treatment programmes, electronic monitoring at the Attorney General’s request, staying within a defined area, curfews, reporting, and for a section 810.1 bond a ban on contact with anyone under 18 and restrictions on internet use. Where the defendant or the applicant is Indigenous, a section 810.03 court must first consider recommending Indigenous support services instead of making an order.

How does a peace bond resolve a criminal charge?

Sometimes the prosecutor will agree to withdraw criminal charges in exchange for having the accused enter into a peace bond. This is a common occurrence in domestic assault related cases where the prosecutor decides not to prosecute the criminal charge, and it is one of several ways a case can end without a conviction.

A peace bond, and the charge withdrawn

Answers: the safety concern, without a trial

The most common resolution. You enter into the recognizance and the Crown withdraws the charge the same day. There is no plea, no finding of guilt and no conviction. What you give up is a year of conditions and the right to have the allegation tested at a trial. Read our page on domestic assault charges for how this plays out in practice.

A withdrawal on its own

Answers: everything — but it has to be earned

A Crown who concludes there is no reasonable prospect of conviction, or that a prosecution is not in the public interest, can withdraw the charge outright. The Attorney General can also direct a stay of proceedings, which ends the case and, if it is not recommenced within a year, is deemed never to have been commenced. The work is in putting the material in front of the Crown early.

Diversion under Part XXII.2

Answers: accountability, without a prosecution

A separate route, rebuilt in 2026. Police and prosecutors must now consider a warning, a referral or an alternative measure before laying a charge or continuing a prosecution. You have to consent, be told of your right to counsel, accept responsibility for the conduct, and the Crown must have enough evidence to prosecute. Complete the measure and the court must dismiss the charge; partial completion can be enough if a prosecution would be unfair.

A conditional discharge

Answers: the conviction — but not the finding of guilt

A different thing altogether. A discharge follows a guilty plea or a finding of guilt: you are deemed not to have been convicted, but the finding of guilt is real and it is recorded. It is not available where the offence carries a minimum punishment or a maximum of 14 years or life. A peace bond involves no finding of guilt at all, which is why it sits ahead of a discharge for most people.

A family court restraining order

Answers: a different question, in a different court

A restraining order under section 46 of Ontario’s Family Law Act or section 35 of the Children’s Law Reform Act is a family court order between family members or former partners. A peace bond is a criminal court order and can be sought against anyone. The two are often confused and they are not interchangeable.

A trial

Answers: the allegation itself

A peace bond is not the right answer in every case. Where the evidence is weak, where a conviction would carry immigration or employment consequences a bond would not, or where the conditions asked for are unworkable, the better course can be to test the case. That choice should be made after disclosure has been reviewed, not before.

A peace bond is a negotiation, and the terms are part of it. Its length, whether contact is barred outright or allowed with conditions, whether a workplace or a home is inside a no-go zone, and the amount on the recognizance are all things that can be argued before you sign.

What happens if you breach a peace bond?

A peace bond is a court order and it is a criminal offence to intentionally violate any of the terms contained in the order. Those alleged to have violated a peace bond may be charged and prosecuted for the crime.

What is breached How it is dealt with Maximum
A peace bond under ss. 810 to 810.2s. 811 A separate criminal offence: breach of recognizance. You are charged and prosecuted for it like any other offence 4 yearsOn indictment. On summary conviction, two years less a day and a fine of up to $5,000
A common law peace bonds. 127 Prosecuted as disobeying a lawful order of a court, because s. 811 reaches only recognizances under ss. 83.3 and 810 to 810.2 2 yearsOn indictment, or as a summary conviction offence
The money on the recognizancess. 770–771 The default is certified and sent to the court. A judge then fixes a hearing, on at least ten days’ notice to you and your sureties, to show cause why the amount should not be forfeited The full amountAt the judge’s discretion, and separate from any prosecution

Two things follow from this. First, the point of a peace bond is that it leaves you without a record — but a conviction for breaching one is a criminal conviction, and it is the single most common way a clean resolution turns into a record. Second, the money and the prosecution are separate: the offender may also be required to pay the monetary amount stipulated on the bond, but that is decided at its own forfeiture hearing, in the judge’s discretion, rather than automatically on a finding of guilt.

Older material, including earlier versions of this page, gives the summary conviction maximum for breaching a peace bond as 18 months. That changed in 2019: section 811(b) now carries no special penalty, so the general summary maximum in section 787 applies — two years less a day, a fine of up to $5,000, or both.

Does a peace bond go on your criminal record?

No — a peace bond is not a conviction and produces no criminal record. What it does produce is a court order, and court orders show up in some places a criminal record does not.

No conviction, no criminal record

Because there is no finding of guilt

A criminal record is a record of convictions. A peace bond involves no plea, no trial and no finding of guilt, so there is nothing to record. That is the whole point of the resolution, and it is why a peace bond is usually preferred over a discharge, which does follow a finding of guilt.

Police can still see the order

Because it has to be enforceable

A peace bond only works if an officer who attends a call can see what you are bound by. The order, its conditions and its expiry date are held in police systems while it is in force, and the occurrence behind it stays in the local police records after that. None of that is a criminal record, but it is not invisible either.

Which record check shows it

Three checks, three answers

Ontario’s Police Record Checks Reform Act, 2015 sets out exactly what each check may disclose. A basic criminal record check must not disclose court orders at all. A criminal record and judicial matters check and a vulnerable sector check must disclose “every court order made against the individual” — but the same schedule tells the provider not to disclose court orders made in relation to a charge that has been withdrawn.

Employment and licensing

Ask which check is being run

Most employers request a basic criminal record check, which will not show a peace bond. Work with children, patients or other vulnerable people usually calls for a vulnerable sector check, which can. If a check matters to your job, your licence or your volunteering, it is worth settling that question before you agree to a bond rather than after.

Travel

Not a conviction — but read your conditions

A peace bond is not a conviction, so it is not a criminal ground of inadmissibility to another country. Two things can still bite: a condition of the bond itself may restrict where you go or require you to remain in a defined area, and a foreign border officer decides admissibility on the information in front of them. Non-citizens should also read our page on the immigration consequences of criminal charges.

When it ends

It expires on its own

A peace bond expires at the end of its term. There is nothing to apply for, no waiting period and no record suspension to seek, because there is no conviction to suspend. If the bond resolved a charge that was withdrawn, the charge is over too.

Why choose Daniel Brown Law?

Daniel Brown Law is a leading Canadian criminal defence firm. Whether a peace bond is the right resolution, and on what terms, is a judgment call our lawyers make every week.

A nationally recognized defence firm

What it means for you

Daniel Brown Law is ranked among Canada’s top criminal law boutiques by Canadian Lawyer, listed for criminal defence by The Globe and Mail and by Best Law Firms, and voted Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services by Toronto Star readers. You are retaining a firm with that record behind it rather than a single lawyer, and your case is staffed by whoever on our team is best placed to handle it.

Resolutions are most of the work

What it means for you

Most criminal cases end without a trial. Knowing which Crown office will consider a peace bond on which kind of allegation, what material moves a screening decision, and when to push for a withdrawal instead, is what decides how your case ends.

The conditions are negotiable

What it means for you

The length, the no-contact and no-go terms, whether a weapons prohibition is added, and the amount on the recognizance are all arguable. We negotiate terms you can actually live with for a year, because a bond you cannot comply with is a breach charge waiting to happen.

Courts across Ontario

What it means for you

We appear in courthouses across the Greater Toronto Area and the rest of the province, and we are available 24 hours a day to help. Peace bond resolutions are often done on a single date — having someone there who knows that courtroom matters.

Recognized by the profession and the public

Daniel Brown Law is ranked among Canada’s top criminal law boutiques by Canadian Lawyer, listed by The Globe and Mail and Best Law Firms for criminal defence, and voted Best Legal Services by Toronto Star readers. Five of its lawyers are recognized by Best Lawyers in Canada for criminal defence.

The Globe and Mail Best Law Firms 2026, Criminal Law

Best Law Firms: Criminal Law

The Globe and Mail, 2026

Canadian Lawyer Top Criminal Law Boutique 2026-27

Top Criminal Law Boutique

Canadian Lawyer, 2026–27

Best Law Firms Canada, Criminal Defence Tier 1, 2026

Criminal Defence, Tier 1

Best Law Firms Canada, 2026

Best Lawyers in Canada 2027, Daniel Brown Law

Best Lawyers in Canada

Criminal Defence, 2027

Toronto Star Readers' Choice winner seal

Toronto Star Readers’ Choice

Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services, repeat winner

Chambers Canada 2027, Ranked in Canada, Daniel Brown Law

Crime, Nationwide

Chambers Canada, 2027

The firm and its lawyers have been repeatedly recognized for excellence in criminal defence:

Our lawyers in the news

Our lawyers are regularly asked by the media to explain how peace bonds work.

What happens between a charge and a peace bond?

From a first appearance to signing a recognizance is usually a matter of months, and almost all of the work happens before the court date on which the bond is entered.

Court sketch of defence counsel standing at the counsel table in a courtroom
  1. The charge, and the conditions you already have

    Most peace bond resolutions start with a criminal charge. Whether you were released by the police or at a bail hearing, you are probably already under no-contact and no-go conditions. Breaching those is a separate offence in its own right, and a breach while the case is live is the fastest way to lose the resolution you are trying to reach.

  2. Disclosure and the Crown’s screening decision

    Your first appearance begins disclosure rather than completing it. The Crown decides whether there is a reasonable prospect of conviction and whether a prosecution is in the public interest. A peace bond becomes realistic when the Crown has a safety concern it wants addressed but a case it is not determined to run.

  3. The negotiation

    This is where the outcome is decided. Counsel puts forward the material that supports a resolution — the absence of a record, counselling already underway, the complainant’s own position where they have one — and argues the terms: the length, what contact is allowed, which addresses are off limits, whether a weapons condition is added, and the amount.

  4. The hearing, and entering the bond

    On the day, the informant’s grounds for the fear are put before the court, usually as a short agreed statement rather than through evidence, you enter into the recognizance and sign it, and the Crown withdraws the charge. You are not asked to plead and you are not asked to admit the allegation.

  5. Twelve months of conditions

    Read the bond, keep a copy of it, and treat the conditions as absolute. If circumstances change, the conditions can be varied on application to the court — but not by agreement between you and the other person, and not by their forgiveness.

  6. Expiry

    At the end of the term the bond ends by itself. There is no conviction to remove and nothing further to do. If money was posted by a surety, it is released once the term has run without a default.

Frequently asked questions about peace bonds

The answers from our original article, corrected to the law as it stands, with the questions people most often ask us about peace bonds in Ontario.

The basics

What is a peace bond?

A peace bond is an official promise made by someone to the Court to abide by certain rules. Usually those rules require a person to “keep the peace and be of good behaviour” and may also require them to refrain from contacting an individual, attending a particular location or from possessing a weapon for a specified period of time.

In the Criminal Code it is a recognizance ordered under section 810. The court does not decide whether you committed an offence; it decides whether someone has reasonable grounds to fear that you will cause personal injury to them, to their intimate partner or to their child, or damage their property.

How long does a peace bond last?

A peace bond under s. 810 of the criminal code can last up to 12 months. The specialised peace bonds in sections 810.01 to 810.2 can run up to two years where the person has a relevant prior conviction — and up to five years for a terrorism peace bond under section 810.011. A common law peace bond is not limited by any of those provisions.

Is a peace bond a criminal conviction or a criminal record?

No. A peace bond is not a conviction, there is no finding of guilt, and it does not create a criminal record. It is a court order, so it can appear on a criminal record and judicial matters check or a vulnerable sector check in Ontario, which both disclose court orders made against a person — though the same rules tell a record check provider not to disclose court orders made in relation to a charge that has been withdrawn. A basic criminal record check does not disclose court orders at all.

What is a common law peace bond?

A common law peace bond comes from the court’s long-standing authority to bind a person over to keep the peace, rather than from any section of the Criminal Code. Because of that, the procedure, the conditions and the length are not defined by statute, and it is sometimes used where a section 810 bond does not fit. The practical difference is in the enforcement: section 811 creates the offence of breaching a recognizance only for bonds under sections 83.3 and 810 to 810.2, so a breach of a common law peace bond is prosecuted instead as disobeying a court order under section 127, which carries a maximum of two years on indictment.

Agreeing to a peace bond

When would someone agree to a peace bond?

Sometimes the prosecutor will agree to withdraw criminal charges in exchange for having the accused enter into a peace bond. This is a common occurrence in domestic assault related cases where the prosecutor decides not to prosecute the criminal charge(s). Read our article on domestic assault for more information on the topic.

It also comes up regularly on criminal harassment, uttering threats, assault and mischief charges — cases where the Crown’s concern is what might happen next rather than what can be proved about what already happened.

Does signing a peace bond mean a person is admitting they committed the crime underlying the bond?

A person who signs a peace bond is not required to acknowledge any criminal wrongdoing before signing the bond. It is not an admission of guilt nor will it result in a criminal record.

By signing the bond, the accused person is only agreeing that in the circumstances of the case, the alleged complainant had reasonable grounds to fear for his or her safety, or the safety of his or her intimate partner or child, or to fear damage to his or her property. The Criminal Code used to refer to a spouse here; since 2019 it refers to an intimate partner, which covers a current or former spouse, common-law partner or dating partner.

What happens if you refuse to sign a peace bond?

You cannot be forced to enter into a recognizance, but refusing has a consequence. Where the court is satisfied that the applicant has reasonable grounds for the fear and you fail or refuse to enter into the bond, section 810(3.01) allows it to commit you to prison for up to 12 months. The same applies under each of the specialised peace bond sections.

If the peace bond has been offered as a way of resolving a criminal charge, refusing it usually means the charge proceeds instead. Whether that is the right call depends on the strength of the case against you and on what a conviction would cost you — which is a conversation to have with a lawyer before the court date.

What evidence is needed for a peace bond?

Less than for a conviction. The court has to be satisfied, on the evidence put before it, that the person who laid the information has reasonable grounds for their fear. The fear must be genuinely held and it must be objectively reasonable in the circumstances; it does not have to be shown that any offence was committed, and nothing has to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. Where a peace bond resolves a criminal charge, the grounds are normally put before the court as a short agreed statement rather than through witnesses.

Living with a peace bond

Can a peace bond be changed or removed?

It can be varied. Section 810(4.1) lets either the person who laid the information or the person bound by the bond apply to the justice or the summary conviction court to vary the conditions fixed in the recognizance. In practice that is how a no-contact condition is relaxed after a reconciliation, or how a no-go area is adjusted around a workplace or a child’s school.

What cannot happen is for the two people involved to agree between themselves to ignore it. Until the court varies or ends the order, the conditions bind you exactly as written.

What happens after a peace bond expires?

Nothing further is required of you. The bond ends at the end of its term, the conditions stop applying, and any money posted on the recognizance is released provided there has been no default. Because there was never a conviction, there is no criminal record to clear and no record suspension to apply for.

Can you travel with a peace bond?

A peace bond is not a conviction, so on its own it is not a criminal ground of inadmissibility to another country. Two practical limits remain. The bond’s own conditions may restrict your movements — some require you to remain within a specified area or to be at your residence at set times — and a foreign border officer makes their own decision on the information available to them. Check the terms of your recognizance before you book anything, and get advice first if you are not a Canadian citizen.

Will a peace bond affect employment?

Usually not. The check most employers run is a basic criminal record check, which under Ontario’s Police Record Checks Reform Act, 2015 must not disclose court orders. A criminal record and judicial matters check and a vulnerable sector check are different: both disclose court orders made against a person, subject to the rule that orders made in relation to a withdrawn charge are not to be disclosed. If your job, your licence or your volunteering depends on a particular kind of check, raise it with your lawyer before agreeing to a bond.

Breaking a peace bond

What happens if a person violates the terms of a peace bond?

A peace bond is a court order and it is a criminal offence to intentionally violate any of the terms contained in the order. Those alleged to have violated a peace bond may be charged and prosecuted for the crime.

The offender may also be required to pay the monetary amount stipulated on the bond. That is decided separately: the default is certified to the court, and a judge fixes a hearing, on at least ten days’ notice to you and to any sureties, at which you can show cause why the amount should not be forfeited. Typically the monetary amount attached to the bond ranges from 500-2000 dollars.

Can a person go to jail for violating a peace bond?

Yes. The maximum penalty for violating a peace bond is four years in jail where the Crown proceeds by indictment. Where the Crown prosecutes the case by way of summary conviction, the maximum is two years less a day, a fine of up to $5,000, or both — section 811(b) sets no special penalty, so the general summary maximum in section 787 applies. Older sources, including earlier versions of this page, give 18 months for the summary route; that figure has been out of date since 2019.

Unlike the peace bond itself, a conviction for breaching one is a criminal conviction and does create a criminal record.

Peace bonds and the alternatives

What is the difference between a peace bond and a restraining order?

A peace bond is a criminal court order made under the Criminal Code, and it can be sought against anyone. A restraining order in Ontario is a family court order under section 46 of the Family Law Act or section 35 of the Children’s Law Reform Act, and it is available only between spouses, former spouses, people who have cohabited, or in respect of a child. Both can restrict contact; they are made in different courts, on different applications, and breaching them engages different provisions.

Is a peace bond better than a conditional discharge?

For most people, yes. A conditional discharge follows a guilty plea or a finding of guilt: you are deemed not to have been convicted, but the finding of guilt exists, it is recorded, and it is disclosed on the broader Ontario record checks for three years. A peace bond involves no plea, no trial and no finding of guilt at all. A discharge is also unavailable where the offence carries a minimum punishment or a maximum of 14 years or life.

What is diversion, and how is it different from a peace bond?

Diversion — now called alternative measures — was rebuilt in 2026. Section 717 of the Criminal Code was repealed and replaced by Part XXII.2, sections 715.44 to 715.6. Police must consider taking no further action, issuing a warning or making a referral before laying a charge, and prosecutors must consider the same before starting or continuing a prosecution. To take part you have to consent, be advised of your right to counsel and accept responsibility for the conduct, and the Crown must have enough evidence to prosecute. If you fully comply, the court must dismiss the charge; if you partly comply, it may dismiss the charge where a prosecution would be unfair.

The difference from a peace bond is the admission. Diversion requires you to accept responsibility for what you did; a peace bond requires you to accept only that someone had reasonable grounds to be afraid.

How do you get a peace bond against someone else?

Anyone who fears on reasonable grounds that another person will cause personal injury to them, their intimate partner or their child, or will damage their property, can lay an information before a justice of the peace. In Ontario that usually starts at the courthouse or with the police. The justice then causes both people to appear, and the court decides whether the fear is reasonable. You do not need to have been the victim of an offence and no charge needs to have been laid.

Torn-paper collage of a pen held just above an unsigned burnt-orange signature line on a blank sheet

Offered a peace bond? Speak to a lawyer before you sign

A peace bond can be the best outcome available in a criminal case — no conviction, no record, and the charge withdrawn. It can also be a year of conditions agreed to too quickly, on a case that should have been fought. Which one it is depends on the disclosure, and on the terms.

For more information on peace bonds and other criminal law related issues, call Daniel Brown Law to arrange a confidential consultation at (416) 297-7200.

Failure to Appear in Court in Ontario: What Happens If You Miss a Court Date

Failure to Appear in Court in Ontario: What Happens If You Miss a Court Date

If you miss a court date in Ontario, the judge will usually issue a warrant for your arrest, and you may be charged with failing to appear under section 145 of the Criminal Code. It is a crime only if you knew you had to be there, failed to attend, and had no lawful excuse. Acting quickly, through a lawyer, gives you the best chance of having the warrant dealt with and the charge avoided.

Generally, it is a criminal offence to intentionally fail to appear in court as directed by a judge or to fail to appear for fingerprints and photographs as directed by a police officer pursuant to a valid court order. (Today the fingerprint date is set by an appearance notice or undertaking that a justice has confirmed, or by a court order.) This article is intended to provide basic legal information about fail to appear charges in Toronto, Ontario. Those looking for advice on this or any criminal charge should consult a criminal lawyer. The lawyers at Daniel Brown Law can be reached for a consultation at (416) 297-7200.

The charge
Criminal Code s. 145Failure to attend court or appear
Crown must prove
You knewyou had to attend, and did not go
Maximum sentence
2 yearsNo minimum; a discharge is possible
At your next bail hearing
Reverse onusIf you were already on release for another charge

I missed my court date. What happens now?

A missed date does not have to become a new criminal charge. What follows depends on the court, on how quickly you act, and on whether police or the Crown choose a charge or a hearing.

Torn-paper collage of a round clock beside a telephone handset, one clock hand in burnt orange

A warrant for your arrest

Usually the first step

What usually occurs when a person misses court is that the judge issues a warrant for their arrest (Criminal Code ss. 512(2) and 597). A judge can delay a bench warrant to give you time to come to court voluntarily, and coming in on your own counts as the warrant being executed.

A hearing instead of a charge

Judicial referral hearing

Where the missed date caused no harm to a victim, no property damage and no financial loss, police can send you to a judicial referral hearing without laying a charge (ss. 496 and 523.1). The justice reviews your release and can take no action. Any charge for the missed date is dismissed and cannot be laid again.

A failure to appear charge

Criminal Code s. 145

Police or the Crown can instead lay a charge of failing to attend court. That charge carries up to two years in jail and, if you were on release for another charge, puts the burden on you to justify your release at your next bail hearing.

Missed a summary conviction trial? The court can hear the trial in your absence or issue a warrant. If it goes ahead without you, no failure to appear charge can be laid for that date without the Attorney General's consent (s. 803).

What does the Crown have to prove for failing to appear in court?

To convict you of failing to appear, the prosecutor must prove every one of these things beyond a reasonable doubt. If any one of them is not proven, the charge fails.

Key considerations

Forgetting is not the same as choosing not to go

The Supreme Court of Canada held in R v Zora, 2020 SCC 14, that bail offences need a guilty mind: you must have known of the obligation and knowingly or recklessly failed to meet it. Carelessness is not enough, and the Court noted that failure to appear cases treat genuine forgetting of a court date as a defence. Judges will test whether the forgetting was genuine.

Fingerprints count too

Missing the date for fingerprints and photographs under the Identification of Criminals Act is its own offence under s. 145 where a justice confirmed your appearance notice or undertaking, a summons set the date, or a court ordered you to attend. A justice can also issue a warrant for it (ss. 512.1 and 512.2).

The record follows you to bail

Attendance in court is the first ground for detaining someone before trial (s. 515(10)(a)). A missed date, and above all a finding of guilt for it, weighs heavily at every later bail hearing.

What are the defences to a failure to appear charge?

Each defence answers one of the four things the Crown must prove. Which ones apply depends on the evidence in your case.

Torn-paper collage of a four-row checklist with three ticks and one box crossed out in burnt orange

There was no valid order to attend

Answers step 1

The Crown must prove the release order, notice, summons or direction that required you to be there. A fingerprint charge also needs an appearance notice or undertaking that a justice confirmed, or a court order.

You genuinely forgot or misunderstood

Answers step 2

The act of failing to appear for court or at the police station for prints and photographs must be intentional. If you honestly forgot the date or misheard it, the Crown cannot prove the knowledge the offence requires.

You did attend

Answers step 3

Court records are not always right. The clerk's certificate can be tested, and the court can allow cross-examination of the person who made it.

You had a lawful excuse

Answers step 4

A lawful excuse usually requires that it would have been impossible for the accused person to attend the appearance: a hospital stay for a significant medical condition, or being in jail on another charge.

Who has to prove the excuse? Before the 2019 bail reforms, the Criminal Code said the proof of a lawful excuse lay on the accused. Those words are gone from the current section 145. The Crown must still prove every element, including your state of mind, beyond a reasonable doubt; in practice the defence brings the evidence of the excuse, such as hospital or custody records.

What is the penalty for failing to appear in court?

Failing to appear is a hybrid offence: the Crown chooses whether to proceed summarily or by indictment. There is no minimum sentence.

Criminal Code s. 145
Charge Maximum on indictment Maximum if summary Minimum
Failing to attend court under a release order, or after appearings. 145(2) 2 years fine up to $5,000, jail up to 2 years less a day, or both None
Failing to appear under an appearance notice or summonss. 145(3), court or fingerprints 2 years fine up to $5,000, jail up to 2 years less a day, or both None
Failing to appear under a police undertakings. 145(4)(b), court or fingerprints 2 years fine up to $5,000, jail up to 2 years less a day, or both None

Maximums are set by Criminal Code s. 145 and, for summary proceedings, s. 787(1). Because there is no minimum and the maximum is under 14 years, a judge can grant a conditional or absolute discharge (s. 730), which is a finding of guilt without a criminal conviction.

The bail consequences often matter more than the sentence. If you were on release for another charge when you missed court, you face a reverse onus at your bail hearing (s. 515(6)(c)). If you are arrested for breaching your release order, the Crown can ask to cancel it (s. 524). In both cases, since July 2026 you must show why you should be released by clearly demonstrating that your release plan addresses the risks the court is concerned about.

Why choose Daniel Brown Law after a missed court date?

The first few days after a missed date decide a lot: whether there is a warrant, whether there is a new charge, and whether you keep your release.

A nationally recognized defence firm

Daniel Brown Law is a leading Canadian criminal defence firm. Canadian Lawyer ranks it among Canada's top criminal law boutiques, The Globe and Mail names it one of Canada's Best Law Firms, Best Law Firms ranks it Tier 1 for criminal defence, and Toronto Star readers have repeatedly voted it Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services.

We move quickly on the warrant

We find out whether a warrant was issued, whether it can still be dealt with in court, and, if not, we arrange a surrender to police so you are not arrested at home or at work.

We argue for no new charge

Where the facts support it, we ask police and the Crown to use a judicial referral hearing or to lay no charge at all, and we press for withdrawal of a charge that has been laid.

Your bail is part of the strategy

A missed date puts your release at risk on the original charge too. Our bail lawyers prepare the release plan, and the surety, that a reverse-onus hearing now demands.

How has the profession recognized Daniel Brown Law?

Daniel Brown Law is ranked among Canada's top criminal law boutiques by Canadian Lawyer, listed by The Globe and Mail and Best Law Firms for criminal defence, and voted Best Legal Services by Toronto Star readers. Five of its lawyers are recognized by Best Lawyers in Canada for criminal defence.

The Globe and Mail Best Law Firms 2026, Criminal Law

Best Law Firms: Criminal Law

The Globe and Mail, 2026

Canadian Lawyer Top Criminal Law Boutique 2026-27

Top Criminal Law Boutique

Canadian Lawyer, 2026–27

Best Law Firms Canada, Criminal Defence Tier 1, 2026

Criminal Defence, Tier 1

Best Law Firms Canada, 2026

Best Lawyers in Canada 2027, Daniel Brown Law

Best Lawyers in Canada

Criminal Defence, 2027

Chambers Canada 2027, Ranked in Canada, Daniel Brown Law

Crime, Nationwide

Chambers Canada, 2027

Toronto Star Readers' Choice winner seal

Toronto Star Readers’ Choice

Best Law Firm and Best Legal Services, repeat winner

Daniel Brown, the firm's founder, is the author of Prosecuting and Defending Sexual Offence Cases (3rd Edition, Emond Publishing's Criminal Law Series), has authored articles for legal journals, and contributes commentary on criminal law to The Toronto Star and other major Canadian news outlets.

The firm and its lawyers have been repeatedly recognized for excellence in criminal defence:

What happens after you miss court and turn yourself in?

A missed date is a problem to solve quickly, not a reason to stay away.

Court sketch of defence counsel standing beside the client in court, with the judge on the bench behind
  1. Call a lawyer as soon as you realize

    The sooner we know, the more options remain, including having the warrant dealt with in court before it is executed.

  2. The warrant is cancelled or a surrender is arranged

    If it is too late to cancel the warrant in court, we arrange for you to surrender to police at a set time, with a plan for release.

  3. Processing and a bail hearing

    Police process the warrant and bring you to court. Your release on the original charge may be reviewed or cancelled, and a new release plan may be needed.

  4. A charge, a hearing, or neither

    We push for no charge, a judicial referral hearing, or withdrawal of the failure to appear count.

  5. Resolution or trial

    If the charge goes ahead, it is resolved or tried on its own evidence, often alongside the original charge. A conviction or sentence can be appealed.

What else do people ask about missing a court date?

Full answers to the questions we hear most often, grouped by topic.

Missed your court date

What happens if I just realized that I missed my court date? What do I do now?

What usually occurs when a person misses court is that the judge issues a warrant for their arrest. In the circumstance when the person misses their appearance for photographs and fingerprints, the police will issue the warrant.

Strictly, it is a justice who issues a warrant for a missed fingerprint date, usually at the request of police (Criminal Code ss. 512.1 and 512.2). Either way, the next step is the same: call a criminal lawyer rather than waiting to be arrested.

Is it possible to have the warrant for my arrest for failing to appear cancelled?

It is possible (depending on when the warrant was issued) to have the warrant cancelled. Usually after two or three days, it will no longer be possible to have the warrant cancelled by the judge. In this instance, the defence lawyer will make arrangements to have the accused person surrender themselves to police to have the warrant processed.

A judge who issues a bench warrant can also postpone it to give the accused a chance to come to court voluntarily, and a voluntary appearance counts as the warrant being executed (s. 597).

If I surrender myself, will I still be charged with failing to appear in court?

Not necessarily - in some instances, a defence lawyer may be able to convince the police officer that the accused person simply forgot the date of their appearance and that the charge of failing to appear in court should not be laid.

Since 2019, police also have a middle option: where the missed date caused no harm to a victim, no property damage and no financial loss, they can send the person to a judicial referral hearing instead of laying a charge (ss. 496 and 523.1).

What will happen to me after I surrender myself to the police for failing to appear?

In almost every instance, a person charged with failing to appear will be required to attend the police station for processing and will then be brought to the courthouse for a bail hearing. If a charge of fail to appear has not been added by the police officer, the accused person will likely be released back on the terms of their previous release associated to their underlying offence (for which they failed to appear). In other cases an accused person may have to go through the process of obtaining bail on the new charge and also risk the possibility of losing their bail on the underlying charge for which they failed to appear.

If the Crown asks to cancel the earlier release under s. 524 and the court finds it was breached, the accused must show why they should be released again, by clearly demonstrating that their release plan addresses the court's concerns. Our bail lawyers prepare for that hearing, and sureties may need to be ready to attend.

What is a judicial referral hearing?

A judicial referral hearing, added to the Criminal Code in 2019 (s. 523.1), is an alternative to a failure to appear or breach charge. It is available where the failure did not cause a victim physical or emotional harm, property damage or economic loss. The justice reviews the person's release conditions and can take no action, replace the release with a new release order, order detention if the prosecutor shows it is justified, or send the person for fingerprints. Any charge for the failure is dismissed, and none can be laid later.

Guilt and defences

What if I forgot my court date? Am I still guilty of failing to appear?

No. The act of failing to appear for court or at the police station for prints and photographs must be intentional. Therefore the crown must prove that you KNEW you had to attend and you chose not to. Forgetting your court date (even if you were negligent by not writing the date down etc.) will not meet the standard necessary for a conviction.

The Supreme Court of Canada confirmed in R v Zora, 2020 SCC 14, that these offences require subjective fault. Recklessness is enough, though: someone who knew of the date and saw a real risk of missing it, and carried on anyway, can still be convicted, and a judge will decide whether a claim of forgetting is believable.

What if I intended to miss my court date but I had a really good reason for doing so?

In some circumstances, the court will accept a lawful (read: very good) excuse from an accused person as to why they missed their court date. Attending a job interview or being “hung over” are not likely considered lawful excuses. A lawful excuse usually requires that it would have been impossible for the accused person to attend the appearance. An example of a lawful excuse might be that the accused person was in the hospital with a significant medical condition that prevented them from being able to attend the court appearance. Another example of a lawful excuse may be that the accused person was in jail on another charge and couldn’t physically attend the appearance as required.

Is missing fingerprints and photographs a crime?

It can be. Failing to attend for fingerprints and photographs under the Identification of Criminals Act is an offence under s. 145 where the date was set by an appearance notice or undertaking that a justice confirmed, by a summons, or by a court order. The same defences apply: you did not know of the date, or you had a lawful excuse.

Penalties and bail

What are the penalties for failing to appear in court?

In some cases, it is possible to be found guilty of failing to appear and not receive a criminal conviction. However, judges can impose jail sentences up to a maximum of two years for the offence. Regardless of what the penalty is, a finding of guilt for failing to appear in court will be a significant factor at any future bail hearing when deciding whether or not the accused person should be released on bail.

The two-year maximum applies when the Crown proceeds by indictment. On a summary prosecution the maximum is a $5,000 fine, two years less a day in jail, or both (s. 787). A finding of guilt without a conviction is a discharge (s. 730).

Can I go to jail for missing a court date?

Missing court can lead to jail in two ways. You can be held in custody after arrest on the warrant if bail is refused, and a sentence for failing to appear can include jail of up to two years. A judge sets any sentence on the facts of the case and the history of the person being sentenced.

How does a failure to appear affect bail on my other charges?

Being charged with failing to appear while on release for another offence puts the burden on you at the bail hearing (s. 515(6)(c)). The Crown can also ask to cancel your existing release under s. 524. Missing court is one of several ways of breaching a release order; see our page on failing to comply with bail conditions.

Missed a court date or charged with failing to appear?

If you or someone you know has been charged with failing to appear for court, you should immediately contact a criminal lawyer to determine your best defence to this type of criminal charge. The lawyers at Daniel Brown Law can be reached for a consultation at (416) 297-7200.