... Skip to main content

Legal Commentary

Appeals

Criminal appeal articles from Daniel Brown Law, covering appeal routes in Ontario, fresh evidence applications, bail pending appeal, and Court of Appeal procedure.

Appealing a Provincial Offences Act Conviction in Ontario

Appealing a Provincial Offences Act Conviction in Ontario

To appeal a provincial offence conviction or sentence in Ontario, whether a traffic ticket, a Highway Traffic Act charge or a regulatory or by-law offence, you must file a notice of appeal within 30 days of the decision, and you normally have to pay the fine first. Appeals from tickets go to a provincial judge of the Ontario Court of Justice. Cases started by a summons or information go to the Ontario Court of Justice or the Superior Court of Justice, depending on who tried the case.

Fresh Evidence on a Criminal Appeal: How the Palmer Test Works

Fresh Evidence on a Criminal Appeal: How the Palmer Test Works

Yes, you can sometimes bring new evidence to a criminal appeal, but only with the court’s permission. The Court of Appeal admits “fresh evidence” when it is in the interests of justice, applying the four-part test from Palmer v The Queen: due diligence, relevance, credibility, and whether the evidence could reasonably have affected the result. When it is admitted on a conviction appeal, the usual result is a new trial. For how appeals work generally, see our criminal appeals overview.

Bail Pending Appeal Lawyers Toronto

Bail Pending Appeal Lawyers Toronto

Bail pending appeal is release from custody while your appeal against a conviction or a sentence waits to be heard, and Daniel Brown Law brings these applications for clients in Toronto and across Ontario. In Ontario a single judge of the Court of Appeal decides it, once a notice of appeal has been filed, and the burden is on the person asking to be released: they must establish that the appeal is not frivolous, that they will surrender back into custody, and that their detention is not necessary in the public interest.

Defending a Crown Appeal: Can the Crown Appeal a Not Guilty Verdict?

Defending a Crown Appeal: Can the Crown Appeal a Not Guilty Verdict?

Yes, the Crown can appeal a not guilty verdict in Ontario, but only in limited circumstances. After a trial on indictment it can appeal an acquittal only on a question of law alone, and it must show that the trial judge’s error might reasonably be thought to have had a material bearing on the acquittal. It can also appeal a sentence, with the Court of Appeal’s leave. The Crown has 30 days to serve its notice of appeal, and your acquittal or sentence stands unless the appeal succeeds.