... Skip to main content

Legal Commentary

Procedural & Charter Rights

Charter rights articles from Daniel Brown Law, covering police searches, entrapment, the right to counsel, and how rights breaches affect a criminal case.

Your Right to Speak With a Lawyer After You Are Arrested: What You Need to Know

Your Right to Speak With a Lawyer After You Are Arrested: What You Need to Know

If you are arrested or detained in Canada, police must tell you right away that you can speak to a lawyer, including free duty counsel, and then give you a real chance to do it before they question you. If you name a particular lawyer, they must help you reach that lawyer. You do not get just “one phone call,” but you do have to pursue the call diligently.

When Can Police Enter Your Home?

When Can Police Enter Your Home?

Police can enter your home in only three ways: with your permission, with a warrant, or under a narrow exception the law recognizes, such as hot pursuit or an emergency that puts someone’s life or safety at risk. Anyone, police included, may walk up to your door and knock. Beyond the door, officers who have no warrant and no exception are there only as long as you allow it, and must leave when you tell them to.

The Rob Ford ‘Crack Video’ Ruling: Who Can See Seized Evidence?

The Rob Ford ‘Crack Video’ Ruling: Who Can See Seized Evidence?

In November 2013, an Ontario judge refused to let a man pictured with Toronto’s mayor see the “crack video” that police had seized. The judge accepted that he had a legal interest in it, but held that access was premature. The ruling shows how Canadian law keeps two questions apart: when a person with an interest in seized evidence may examine it, and when the public and the media may see court records and exhibits.

Public Mischief Lawyers Toronto

Public Mischief Lawyers Toronto

Daniel Brown Law defends public mischief charges in Toronto and across the GTA. Public mischief is a criminal offence under section 140 of the Criminal Code. It is committed by someone who, intending to mislead, causes the police to start or continue an investigation by making a false accusation, casting suspicion on someone else or away from themselves, reporting a crime that never happened, or falsely reporting a death. It is a hybrid offence with a maximum of five years in jail. The intent to mislead is where most public mischief cases are fought.

The Entrapment Defence in Canada: When Police Go Too Far

The Entrapment Defence in Canada: When Police Go Too Far

Undercover police work and sting operations are legal in Canada. Entrapment happens when police cross one of two lines: they offer someone the chance to commit a crime without a reasonable suspicion, or they go further than offering a chance and induce the crime. It is not a defence that leads to an acquittal. If the accused proves it, the judge stays the charge as an abuse of process.

How a Criminal Conviction or Guilty Plea Can Affect a Civil Lawsuit

How a Criminal Conviction or Guilty Plea Can Affect a Civil Lawsuit

Yes. In Ontario, a criminal conviction or discharge can be used in a civil lawsuit about the same events. Under s. 22.1 of the Evidence Act, it is proof that the person committed the crime unless there is evidence to the contrary, and courts rarely let anyone relitigate it. A guilty plea counts the same way, so what you do in the criminal case can decide fault, damages and even accident benefits in the civil one. An acquittal works differently, because a civil court only needs proof on a balance of probabilities.